Bergen County SealBergenHub
GoodFellas Restaurant
👑#1 Best Italian Restaurant in Garfield, NJGet Award

GoodFellas Restaurant

4.7
500+ reviews$30-70
Food & DiningItalian restaurantItalian Restaurant
Website(973) 478-4000Directions
$0.00 raised this season·currently #1 in Garfield·#1 — defend your spot

661 Midland Ave

Warm restaurant & bar serving large portions of classic Italian food since 1991.

Sponsored Ranking

Ordered by owner and customer bids — bought, not earned. BergenHub promotes Bergen County businesses; it doesn't rate service quality.

In Garfield

#16 / Food

View category →

In Garfield overall

#241 of all businesses

Italian Restaurant

#1 in town

Composite score

1 / 100

rating · quality · popularity

Review quality analysis

Computed from 17 text reviews using BergenHub's quality scoring (sentiment, owner responsiveness, review depth).

Positive sentiment53%
Owner responsiveness0%
Negative signal18%
Sentiment balance84%

What customers mention

owner operated1family friendly1

Nearby similar stores

Google's picks for similar italian restaurant near Garfield.

Customer reviews

Ratings and comments from Google and BergenHub members, combined into one score. Sign in with a verified-email account to add yours.

See all on Google →
Checking your account…
  • GGoogle reviewer
    Sep 5, 2026

    Only been to the restaurant once<br>Nice restaurant clean good atmosphere good service however the linguine with clam sauce was absolutely disgusting

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Sep 2, 2026

    Host and wate staff are very gracious. Was too full to order birthday desserts but a plate of cookies was supplied. Anyway!!

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Aug 29, 2026

    I have no idea how this place isn't five stars yet! My little family and I are from Virginia, but we come to Jersey often to visit the city and attend Yankees games without having to stay in the city all night. This is officially our new go-to spot and was absolutely worth the seven-hour drive!<br><br>The staff was amazing, and the entire restaurant had such a warm, family-friendly atmosphere. I've never experienced anything like it! The teamwork among the staff was incredible, and the pasta was some of the most delicious I've ever had. From beginning to end, it truly felt like we were having dinner at Nonna's house. It's the perfect spot, and we can't wait to come back!

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    Aug 16, 2026

    Not impressed, first they have there "own version" of clams casino which was more of a baked clam, then a dried out pork chop along with a $230 tab. Much better Italian food in Jersey than this place.

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Aug 13, 2026

    Rating only — no comment.

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    Aug 6, 2026

    Rating only — no comment.

Sponsored Ranking. Positions are bought through owner and customer bids, not awarded on quality. BergenHub helps Bergen County businesses get discovered; it does not rate their service.