Bergen County SealBergenHub
Bayside Bull
🥉#3 Best Restaurant (Other) in Edgewater, NJGet Award

Bayside Bull

4.7
500+ reviews$10-20
Food & DiningBarbecue restaurantRestaurant (Other)
Website(443) 726-4516Directions
$0.00 raised this season·currently #3 in Edgewater·next bid +$1.00 leaderboard value to take #2·$0.00 behind #1

108 W Central Ave

Fast action sandwich carryout, featuring BBQ and sliced meats. Premium, full-service caterer providing the entire array of food service, bar service, staffing, party rental items, and more!

Sponsored Ranking

Ordered by owner and customer bids — bought, not earned. BergenHub promotes Bergen County businesses; it doesn't rate service quality.

In Edgewater

#6 / Food

View category →

In Edgewater overall

#146 of all businesses

Restaurant (Other)

#3 in town

Composite score

1 / 100

rating · quality · popularity

Review quality analysis

Computed from 17 text reviews using BergenHub's quality scoring (sentiment, owner responsiveness, review depth).

Positive sentiment41%
Owner responsiveness0%
Negative signal0%
Sentiment balance100%

What customers mention

honest upfront1

Nearby similar stores

Google's picks for similar restaurant (other) near Edgewater.

Customer reviews

Ratings and comments from Google and BergenHub members, combined into one score. Sign in with a verified-email account to add yours.

See all on Google →
Checking your account…
  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    Sep 1, 2026

    The atmosphere is what you would expect from a open pit restaurant. But most people buy the food for takeout and you can call ahead for that but, they are so quick here you really don't need to do that they also do catering.

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Aug 27, 2026

    Always great food, great people, great service

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    Aug 26, 2026

    Im the reviewer and you just got 5 stars

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    Aug 24, 2026

    Haven't been in for 10 years, moved to eastern shore. My wife and I stopped in an it was one of the best sandwiches we've had in years, honestly probably since the last time we were there. Keep it up

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    Aug 15, 2026

    Might be my new favorite spot for pit beef. The perfect amount of smoke with char'd bits cooked to temp. Protein stacked high, would be a "large" at any other spot but this is their usual.<br><br>Great kaiser roll, didn't fall apart. Small menu, fast moving. Onions sliced on a deli slicer for the perfect bite. Awesome selection of sauces to choose from.<br><br>The only downside is I'm over an hour away.

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Aug 9, 2026

    I used them to cater my son's graduation party, and they were excellent. The food was eaten almost down to the last pound and everyone raved about it. I'll definitely use them for future gatherings. (We ordered Pit Beef, Pit Turkey, Sausage and Peppers, Mac & Cheese, Baked Beans, and Potato Salad.)

Sponsored Ranking. Positions are bought through owner and customer bids, not awarded on quality. BergenHub helps Bergen County businesses get discovered; it does not rate their service.