Mightylicious

Review quality analysis

Computed from 8 text reviews using BergenHub's quality scoring (sentiment, owner responsiveness, review depth).

Nearby similar stores

Google's picks for similar bakery near Wood-ridge.

• Chris's Cookies
  30+ reviewsBakery
• Goodie Girl
  < 30 reviewsWholesale bakery
• Mitsubishi International Food Ingredients Inc - Hackensack Office
  < 30 reviewsFood manufacturer

• GGoogle reviewer

  Mar 25, 2026

  Sorry but these cookies are disgustingly sweet. Could not get the sweet taste off my tongue for a while. Texture was good but could not get past the sweetness. I had the oatmeal coconut. If only you didn't use so much sugar! Will not be purchasing these again.

• GGoogle reviewer

  Nov 3, 2024

  I had never seen your cookies before last week. Was shopping for 4 legged animals and decided to slip in a treat for me. Your cookies were delicious. Simply delicious.

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  May 16, 2024

  looks nothin like its supposed too and is dry with a mealy texture... not at all like the pic on the package... check it out

• GGoogle reviewer

  Nov 1, 2023

  Good cookies.

• GGoogle reviewer

  Sep 30, 2023

  Mighty Licious cookies, I was given a bundle of four, of assorted packages of your cookies, however, they are really bad. The Short Bread were the best.<br>My daughter & her husband did not like them either; these cookies are terrible. First they are several shades lighter than the bag and look under baked. The package shows a golden brown cookie but these are like khaki or even lighter.<br>Their texture was like a compressed flour. Chalky and crumbly not crunchy or chewy.<br>The flavor was also so off. There was a taste like spoiled dairy through them; not to mention the raw flour flavor since they were way under done. I will not recommend them to anyone..sorry. ( I did add pecans to some of the cookies to elp making them palatable.).

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Sep 23, 2023

  Most commerical gluten free stuff is not great, let be honest.<br><br>Mightylicious Brown Butter chocolate chip cookies, however, are really bad. I grabbed a bag at a local store and these things are terrible. First they are several shades lighter than the bag and look under baked. The package shows a golden brown cookie but these are like khaki or even lighter.<br><br>Their texture was like a compressed flour. Chalky and crumbly not crunchy or chewy.<br><br>The flavor was also so off. There was a taste like spoiled dairy through them; not to mention the raw flour flavor since they were way under done.<br><br>For $9 a bag unfortunately I'm not going to try another flavor. Just not worth it. If the one's I tried could get past whatever panel of food tasters they had then I can't imagine any other flavor being palatable.