Bergen County SealBergenHub
South River Pizza & Subs

South River Pizza & Subs

4.3
100+ reviews$10-20
Food & DiningPizza restaurantPizza Restaurant
(410) 956-1160Directions
$0.00 raised this season·currently #8 in Edgewater·next bid +$1.00 leaderboard value to take #7·$0.00 behind #1

58 Central Ave W

Sponsored Ranking

Ordered by owner and customer bids — bought, not earned. BergenHub promotes Bergen County businesses; it doesn't rate service quality.

In Edgewater

#65 / Food

View category →

In Edgewater overall

#352 of all businesses

Pizza Restaurant

#8 in town

Composite score

1 / 100

rating · quality · popularity

Review quality analysis

Computed from 16 text reviews using BergenHub's quality scoring (sentiment, owner responsiveness, review depth).

Positive sentiment31%
Owner responsiveness0%
Negative signal6%
Sentiment balance88%

Nearby similar stores

Google's picks for similar pizza restaurant near Edgewater.

Customer reviews

Ratings and comments from Google and BergenHub members, combined into one score. Sign in with a verified-email account to add yours.

See all on Google →
Checking your account…
  • GGoogle reviewer
    Aug 7, 2026

    Have you ever gone into a place not expecting much and just looking for food. Well that was what I did today but to my surprise I found a really good sub shop. I got the best steak and cheese sub and my daughter got a Five star Italian cold cut. Happy to have found this hidden gem. A must stop if in the area.

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Jun 26, 2026

    So good

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    May 12, 2026

    Their gyros are great. Salads are fresh. Tomatoes in particular are great even during the winter.

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    May 2, 2026

    Delicious pizza. We got it togo and was really good.

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    Apr 26, 2026

    I was hosting a party for my son. I had 50 guests and the venue recommended South River Pizza and Subs. Jack was proactive in his communications. Provided exceptional food quality, professional staff, and seamless, organized service that reduced my stress. Jack was great to work with, guiding me through varied food options, servings, and prices. He delivered the food on time, it was hot and fresh. We went with pizzas, wings, chicken strips, and salad. Everything was delicious but the salad was my favorite. My guests appreciated the crisp vegetables with a variety of dressings. I had to take my family in as a follow up.

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Apr 10, 2026

    Way over priced for pizza that reminds me of cheap bowling alley pizza. The 2 medium deal is 30$. Cheese is overly chewy and the sauce feels old. My family was very surprised at the high star rating. Would not recommend as edgewater and Annapolis have much better options. We had cheese steaks a while ago that were good, so very surprised at the pizza.

Sponsored Ranking. Positions are bought through owner and customer bids, not awarded on quality. BergenHub helps Bergen County businesses get discovered; it does not rate their service.