Mikayla's Thriftique

Review quality analysis

Computed from 18 text reviews using BergenHub's quality scoring (sentiment, owner responsiveness, review depth).

Nearby similar stores

Google's picks for similar antique, thrift & consignment store near Rutherford.

• Hana Mission Thrift Store Belleville
  100+ reviewsThrift store
• Unleashed Thrift
  30+ reviewsThrift store
• Passaic Thrift Store
  30+ reviewsThrift store

• GGoogle reviewer

  Aug 25, 2026

  Rude owner

  Owner response · Aug 30, 2026

  Can you explain further?

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Aug 22, 2026

  I love this place! Sarah, the owner is so nice and super helpful if you have any questions. I just came across this shop while driving one day and now it's on my regular thrift rotation. It's clean and items are easy to sift through. Also, there's ALWAYS new things coming in so I'm destined to leave with SOMETHING. A perk is puppy Lulu who is always happy to greet customers! Absolutely stop in for some great finds!

  Owner response · Aug 30, 2026

  Ruff! Ruff! Lulu says thank you for the kind review! We much appreciate the time and thoughtful review! Welcome back anytime!

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Jul 30, 2026

  <br><br>I've found so many special tchotchkes at Mikayla's Thriftique over the years, and every interaction I've had with the owner has been memorable. Sara is an incredibly hardworking mother who pours her heart and soul into this store, and it truly shows. She has brought so much life to Park Avenue, and as a bonus, parking is always easy!<br><br>Every time you walk through the door, you're greeted with a warm smile and a genuine welcome. You never know what you'll find until you step inside. One visit you might stumble upon a beautiful, brand-new scented candle that's perfect for your bathroom, and the next you might discover the perfect dress to give as a gift. The selection is constantly changing and includes purses, pet supplies, home decor, small appliances, dining sets, shoes, clothing, hats, board games, children's toys, electronics, collectibles, baby items, vintage treasures, accessories, and even designer pieces. My advice? Take your time and look carefully, you never know

  Owner response · Aug 7, 2026

  What an honor it is to serve you as a customer! You are a shining bright light in a world where negativity runs rampant. You are such a staunch supporter in recycling and reusing - and for a super mom to make the time to write this review - just shows your wonderful character. Thank you from<br>the bottom of our hearts. We cherish your spirit, respect your patronage and will always remember your kindness !!

• GGoogle reviewer

  Jul 28, 2026

  I came in saw a woman behind the counter, I said hi do buy things, she said no, that's it not friendly, I took a quick look around, place is packed, no room to walk, I left the store, didn't say anything.

  Owner response · Aug 7, 2026

  Hi - it's a shame that you're giving a 1 star because I wouldn't buy from you. And that's not what happened, so please be accurate. You got upset because I wouldn't buy from you. I buy from other resources because a few folks like yourself are too aggressive. It's sad that you're giving a one star because you're so angry. I raise my daughter partially on this store that I've had now for 3 years. We will thrive REGARDLESS. I only wish you the best in trying to sell your items.

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Jul 28, 2026

  a little crowded, but charming and lots of options. the woman behind the counter is always so helpful and so kind. we NEED more retail in town, and this store has been an amazing addition.

  Owner response · Aug 7, 2026

  Thanks so much for your review. Yes, it's a little crowded as it's a thrift but also when it's rainy I can't place items outside - I don't turn away donations when given so it becomes harder to be creative with the space. We work on spacing things out when there's time. We just installed a new large shelf in the back and will continue to make it an even better experience.

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Jul 28, 2026

  When i needed something to wear to a themed party Sara helped me in a pinch! I am so grateful for this store in my town. Great items for everyone!

  Owner response · Aug 7, 2026

  Thank you, Eleanor! Im so glad it all worried out for,ya!